Evaluating & Choosing Ideas
After generating many ideas, you need to choose which to pursue. Evaluating ideas well saves months of effort on the wrong thing. The goal is not to find a perfect idea, but to pick the most promising one to test cheaply and quickly.
Four lenses for judging ideas
| Lens | Key question | Evidence to look for |
|---|---|---|
| Problem | Does this solve a painful, frequent problem? | Customer interviews, existing workarounds, money already spent |
| Market | Are there enough customers who can pay? | Rough count of customers, their spending, growth trends (see Market Sizing) |
| Founder fit | Are we the right team to build this? | Relevant skills, access to customers, genuine interest for several years |
| Feasibility | Can we build and deliver it with our resources? | Technical difficulty, cost to start, regulation, time to first test |
The design firm IDEO describes a similar balance with three questions: is it desirable (do people want it?), feasible (can it be built?) and viable (can it sustain a business?). The best ideas sit where all three overlap.
A weighted scoring matrix
Score each idea from 1 (weak) to 5 (strong) on each criterion. Because some criteria matter more, multiply each score by a weight, then add up. Weights should total 100% so the final score stays on the same 1–5 scale.
Njeri and her two co-founders in Nyeri are comparing three ideas for helping small-scale farmers. They agree on weights: problem 35%, market 25%, founder fit 20%, feasibility 20%.
| Idea | Problem (×0.35) | Market (×0.25) | Fit (×0.20) | Feasibility (×0.20) | Weighted total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A. SMS weather and planting alerts | 3 | 4 | 3 | 5 | 3.65 |
| B. Drone crop spraying service | 4 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 2.95 |
| C. Shared transport to market for produce | 5 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 4.15 |
Check idea C: 5×0.35 = 1.75; 4×0.25 = 1.00; 4×0.20 = 0.80; 3×0.20 = 0.60; total 4.15. Idea A: 3×0.35 = 1.05; 4×0.25 = 1.00; 3×0.20 = 0.60; 5×0.20 = 1.00; total 3.65. Idea B: 1.40 + 0.75 + 0.40 + 0.40 = 2.95. Always check the arithmetic; a small error can change your ranking.
Idea C scores highest. One of the co-founders grew up in a farming family and knows that produce often rots waiting for transport, which strengthens founder fit. The team decides to test C first, keeping A as a backup because it is cheap to build.
Find your riskiest assumption
Every idea rests on assumptions. Before investing, list them and ask which one, if wrong, would kill the idea. Test that one first. For Njeri's transport idea, assumptions include:
- Farmers will pay a fee per crate for shared transport. (Riskiest: test first.)
- Enough farmers in one area harvest at the same time to fill a vehicle.
- Vehicle owners will rent on a per-trip basis at a fair price.
A simple test: offer one shared trip next market day, collect bookings and small deposits by M-Pesa, and see how many farmers commit.
Quick filters
Before scoring in detail, cross out ideas that fail any of these:
- Is it legal and ethical?
- Could we run a first test within a month for an amount we can afford to lose?
- Would at least some customers pay, or would someone else (an employer, a cooperative, a government body) pay on their behalf?
- Would we still want to work on this in two years?
Treating a scoring matrix as an exact answer. The scores are educated guesses, and a team can unconsciously adjust them to favour the idea it already likes. Use the matrix to structure the discussion, then go and collect real evidence from customers.
Key points
- Judge ideas through four lenses: problem, market, founder fit and feasibility.
- IDEO's desirability, feasibility and viability offer a similar check.
- A weighted scoring matrix makes comparisons more honest; check the arithmetic.
- Identify the riskiest assumption behind your chosen idea and test it first.
Tip: use the ← and → keys to move between pages.
