Ideate: Generating Solutions
In the ideate mode, you generate a wide range of possible solutions to your "How might we" question, then choose the most promising ones to prototype. The aim is to go beyond the obvious first answer and find ideas that are both creative and practical.
Setting up a good ideation session
- Start with a clear HMW question from the define mode, written where everyone can see it.
- Mix people: different courses, ages and experiences produce more varied ideas.
- Timebox: short, energetic rounds (10–20 minutes) work better than long, tiring ones.
- Make it visual: one idea per sticky note, with a quick sketch if possible.
Brainstorming
Advertising executive Alex Osborn popularised brainstorming in the mid-20th century. Its core idea is to separate generating ideas from judging them. Useful ground rules, similar to those used at IDEO:
- Defer judgement: no "that won't work" during the session.
- Go for quantity.
- Build on the ideas of others ("yes, and...").
- Encourage wild ideas.
- Stay focused on the question.
- One conversation at a time.
SCAMPER
SCAMPER is a checklist of prompts, developed by Bob Eberle from Osborn's earlier questions. You apply each prompt to an existing product, process or idea to spark new ones.
| Letter | Prompt | Example: helping vendors recover credit |
|---|---|---|
| Substitute | What could you replace? | Replace the paper notebook with a voice note recorded at the time of sale |
| Combine | What could you join together? | Combine debt records with an M-Pesa payment link |
| Adapt | What could you borrow from elsewhere? | Adapt chama savings rules: small regular repayments |
| Modify | What could you make bigger, smaller or different? | Make reminders very small and friendly, not formal demands |
| Put to another use | Who else could use this? | Debt records could help vendors show lenders their sales history |
| Eliminate | What could you remove? | Remove the need for a smartphone by using SMS or USSD |
| Reverse / rearrange | What if you did it the other way round? | Customers pay a small deposit before taking goods on credit |
Other quick techniques
- Crazy 8s: fold a sheet into eight panels and sketch eight ideas in eight minutes. Speed stops you overthinking.
- Worst possible idea: brainstorm terrible solutions, then flip each one. "Shame debtors on a public noticeboard" flips into "praise reliable payers privately".
- Role-storming: ask how a particular person (a bank, a matatu tout, a grandmother) would solve the problem.
Choosing ideas to prototype
After diverging, converge. Cluster similar ideas, then use one or more selection methods:
- Dot voting: each person places three dots on ideas they find most promising.
- Categories: pick one "most likely to delight", one "most rational" and one "long shot". This keeps bold ideas in play.
- Impact vs effort: place ideas on a 2×2 grid and start with high-impact, low-effort ones.
Aim to take two or three ideas forward to prototyping, not just one. Testing alternatives side by side teaches you more.
Four friends in Kigali worked on "How might we help university students eat healthily on a tight budget?" In a 15-minute brainstorm they produced 52 ideas. SCAMPER added 18 more, including "eliminate cooking" (pre-portioned meal kits needing only a kettle) and "combine" (group buying with hostel mates). Dot voting picked three: a weekly group-buy of vegetables, a cheap-recipe WhatsApp channel and a shared-cooking rota. They chose to prototype the group-buy and the recipe channel because both could be tested within a week for very little money.
Letting the most senior or loudest person decide which ideas survive. Use silent writing and voting so everyone's ideas are considered. Also, do not judge ideas by how "techy" they are; a simple, non-digital solution may serve users far better.
Key points
- Ideation starts from a clear "How might we" question and separates generating from judging.
- Brainstorming rules (popularised by Osborn) encourage quantity, wild ideas and building on others.
- SCAMPER offers seven prompts for transforming existing ideas.
- Converge with dot voting or impact vs effort, and take two or three ideas to prototyping.
Tip: use the ← and → keys to move between pages.
