Generating Ideas
Once you have chosen a problem, you need ideas for solving it, and the first idea is rarely the best. Idea generation is about producing many possible solutions before judging them, so you have real options to choose from.
Diverge, then converge
Good idea generation has two separate phases. First you diverge: produce as many ideas as possible without criticising them. Then you converge: compare, combine and select. Mixing the two (criticising each idea as it appears) kills creativity, because people stop suggesting anything unusual. You will see this same rhythm in design thinking.
Techniques that work
1. Brainstorming with rules
Set a timer for 15 minutes and aim for quantity. Write every idea on a separate sticky note. Defer judgement, build on others' ideas and welcome wild suggestions. A wild idea can often be tamed into a practical one.
2. Brainwriting
Each person silently writes three ideas on a sheet in five minutes, then passes the sheet on; the next person builds on them. This stops the loudest person dominating and gives quieter team members equal voice.
3. Analogy: "Who has solved something similar?"
Look at how another industry handles a similar problem. Ride-hailing apps match drivers and passengers; could the same matching idea connect farmers with tractor owners? Mobile money sends value by SMS; could school fee reminders work the same way?
4. Combine existing things
Many good ideas combine two ordinary parts: a WhatsApp catalogue plus pay-on-delivery; a chama savings group plus an app that records contributions.
5. Constraints
Ask "How would we solve this with no smartphone?" or "with KES 5,000?" or "in one day?" Constraints push you towards simple, affordable solutions that often suit your customers better.
6. Business model patterns
The same problem can be solved with different ways of charging: subscription, pay-per-use, freemium, a marketplace that takes commission, or advertising. Changing the model can create a new idea even when the product stays similar.
Where great ideas come from
| Source of advantage | Question |
|---|---|
| Insider knowledge | What do I understand about this industry or community that outsiders miss? |
| New technology | What is now cheap or possible that wasn't five years ago (cheap smartphones, AI tools, solar)? |
| New rules or habits | What changed in regulation or behaviour that creates a gap? |
| Underserved groups | Who is ignored by existing products: rural customers, informal workers, people with disabilities? |
Three TVET students in Kisumu chose this problem: "Fish traders at the beach lose fish to spoilage because ice is expensive and far away." In a 20-minute brainwriting session they produced 31 ideas, including:
- A solar-powered cold box rented by the day (technology).
- A shared ice delivery route ordered by SMS (analogy with delivery apps).
- A WhatsApp group that connects traders to buyers before boats land, so fish sells faster (combination).
- Teaching fish-drying techniques for unsold stock (constraint: no electricity).
Only after the session did they discuss which ideas were realistic. The shared-route idea had not occurred to any of them before they started writing.
A simple idea-generation session
- Write the problem statement at the top of a board.
- Warm up for three minutes with a silly prompt (100 uses for a bottle top).
- Brainwrite for 10–15 minutes, aiming for at least 10 ideas per person.
- Group similar ideas into clusters and give each cluster a name.
- Each person gets three votes (dots) to mark the most promising ideas.
- Take the top three to the next step: Evaluating & Choosing Ideas.
Falling in love with the first idea and defending it against all others. Another mistake is keeping ideas secret for fear of theft. In practice, ideas are cheap and execution is hard; talking openly gets you feedback that is far more valuable than secrecy.
Key points
- Separate generating ideas (diverging) from judging them (converging).
- Use structured techniques: brainstorming, brainwriting, analogy, combination and constraints.
- Changing the business model can create a new idea even with a similar product.
- Aim for many ideas first; the best one is rarely the first.
Tip: use the ← and → keys to move between pages.
