Adaptive Leadership
Some problems have known answers that an expert can deliver. Others, like changing a community's attitudes or reinventing a struggling organisation, require people themselves to learn, let go of old habits and change. Adaptive leadership is about mobilising people to tackle these tough challenges.
What the approach says
Adaptive leadership was developed by Ronald Heifetz of Harvard's Kennedy School, first in Leadership Without Easy Answers (1994) and later with Alexander Grashow and Marty Linsky in The Practice of Adaptive Leadership (2009). It focuses on how leaders help followers do adaptive work: the learning and change needed to thrive in a new reality. The leader does not solve the problem for people; the leader helps people solve it themselves.
Three kinds of situational challenge
| Type | Problem definition | Solution | Who does the work |
|---|---|---|---|
| Technical problems | Clear | Known; can be fixed with existing expertise | The leader or expert |
| Technical and adaptive challenges | Clear | Not clear; requires learning | Leader and followers together |
| Adaptive challenges | Not clear; requires learning to even understand | Requires learning | Mainly the followers, with the leader's help |
A common leadership failure is treating an adaptive challenge as a technical one: for example, responding to low morale with a new attendance policy when the real issue is a loss of trust.
Six leader behaviours
| Behaviour | What it involves |
|---|---|
| Get on the balcony | Step back from the action to see the bigger picture: patterns, conflicts and what is really going on. |
| Identify adaptive challenges | Diagnose whether the challenge is technical or adaptive. Adaptive challenges often involve values, beliefs, gaps between what people say and do, or avoided issues. |
| Regulate distress | Keep stress at a productive level: enough to motivate change, not so much that people are overwhelmed. This includes creating a holding environment, a safe space to tackle hard issues. |
| Maintain disciplined attention | Help people stay focused on the hard work and resist work avoidance, such as blaming others, denial or distraction. |
| Give the work back to the people | Resist the urge to solve everything; trust people to take responsibility. |
| Protect leadership voices from below | Listen to people on the margins or with less status, even if their views are uncomfortable. |
An example
In a village in Turkana, a community-based organisation finds that girls are dropping out of primary school. Building a new classroom (a technical fix) has not helped.
The coordinator, Lokwang, gets on the balcony and realises the real challenge involves beliefs about early marriage, the value of girls' education and household labour: an adaptive challenge. He creates a holding environment through regular dialogue sessions with elders, mothers and girls, and keeps tension productive by moving step by step. When some elders try to steer meetings back to asking for more funding (work avoidance), he gently returns attention to the main issue. He gives the work back: the community designs its own plan, including flexible chores schedules and mentorship by women who finished school. He makes sure girls' own voices are heard in meetings (protecting voices from below).
Strengths
- Leadership as a process focused on helping people change, rather than on the leader's traits.
- Follower-centred. It emphasises followers doing the work and growing.
- Distinguishes problem types, which helps leaders avoid offering technical fixes for adaptive problems.
- Practical concepts such as getting on the balcony and the holding environment are easy to remember and use.
Criticisms
- Little empirical research has tested its claims.
- Conceptualisation needs refinement. How the components fit together is not fully explained.
- Abstract and broad. Its prescriptions can be hard to turn into specific actions.
- Moral dimension unclear. It suggests leaders help people grow, but does not clearly state which values should guide the change.
How to apply it
- Ask: is there a known fix? If yes, it's technical; fix it. If not, treat it as adaptive.
- Get on the balcony after each meeting: what patterns did you notice?
- Turn the heat up or down: raise urgency when people are complacent, slow down when they are overwhelmed.
- Name work avoidance kindly but clearly when it happens.
- Hand back problems with a question: "What do you think we should try?"
Key points
- Heifetz's adaptive leadership helps people face challenges without easy answers.
- Challenges can be technical, technical and adaptive, or adaptive.
- Six behaviours: get on the balcony, identify adaptive challenges, regulate distress, maintain disciplined attention, give the work back, protect voices from below.
- The leader mobilises people to do the adaptive work themselves.
Tip: use the ← and → keys to move between pages.
