Skip to content
Kuza Ndoto Academy

Gender & Leadership

All levelsChapter 5 · Page 20 of 264 min readUpdated 15 Nov 2026

Women are well represented among graduates and workers across East Africa, yet they remain under-represented in top leadership roles in business, government and religious institutions. This page looks at what research says about gender differences in leadership, the barriers women face and how to build fairer paths.

What the research says

From glass ceiling to labyrinth

The glass ceiling is an invisible barrier that prevents women from rising to the top levels of organisations. Alice Eagly and Linda Carli (2007) proposed a different metaphor: the labyrinth. Rather than a single barrier near the top, women face many twists, detours and dead ends throughout their careers. The labyrinth suggests that the journey is difficult but possible, and that there are many points where organisations can help.

Glass ceiling Top roles barrier near the top Career start Labyrinth Top roles bias & stereotypes caring responsibilities fewer mentors Career start
Figure 1. The glass ceiling pictures one barrier just below the top. Eagly and Carli's (2007) labyrinth pictures many detours throughout a career: harder, but passable, and open to help at every turn.

Michelle Ryan and Alex Haslam (2005) identified the glass cliff: women are more likely than men to be appointed to leadership positions when an organisation is in crisis, making failure more likely.

Do men and women lead differently?

  • A meta-analysis by Eagly and Blair Johnson (1990) found women tended to lead in a somewhat more democratic, participative way than men.
  • A 2003 meta-analysis by Eagly, Mary Johannesen-Schmidt and Marloes van Engen found women were slightly more transformational and used more contingent reward.
  • Overall, research has found no general difference in how effective men and women are as leaders, although context matters, for example whether a role is traditionally seen as masculine.

Explaining the gap

ExplanationWhat research shows
Human capitalWomen often have fewer chances for developmental assignments, mentoring and sponsorship, and carry more family and domestic responsibilities. The claim that women are less committed to work is not supported.
Gender differencesDifferences in leadership style and effectiveness are small. Some research suggests women are less likely to negotiate for themselves, often because doing so can bring social penalties.
Prejudice and biasStereotypes link leadership with traditionally masculine qualities. Virginia Schein's research in the 1970s described this as "think manager, think male".

The double bind

Women are often expected to be communal (warm, supportive), while leaders are expected to be agentic (assertive, decisive). Eagly and Steven Karau's role congruity theory (2002) explains the result: a woman leader who is warm may be seen as not tough enough, while one who is assertive may be seen as cold or unlikeable. This double bind means women must constantly balance competing expectations.

An example

Example

Two candidates apply to chair a youth SACCO in Eldoret: Mercy and David, with similar experience. At the interview, Mercy firmly challenges the board on loan defaults; some board members describe her as "aggressive". When David makes the same points, they call him "decisive". This is the double bind in action.

A board member who has attended bias training points out the difference and suggests scoring both candidates against agreed criteria. With structured scoring, Mercy edges ahead and is appointed. She then sets up a mentoring circle for young women members who want to stand for leadership roles.

Strengths and limitations of the research

  • Strength: a large body of evidence, including meta-analyses, gives a clear picture of barriers and differences.
  • Strength: it moves the debate from blaming women to examining organisations, stereotypes and structures.
  • Limitation: much research comes from Western countries; experiences in African settings may differ.
  • Limitation: gender interacts with age, class, ethnicity, religion and disability, which simple male/female comparisons can miss.
Note

Policy can make a difference. Women have held a majority of seats in Rwanda's lower house of parliament since the 2008 election, and Kenya's 2010 Constitution says no more than two-thirds of the members of elective or appointive public bodies should be of the same gender.

How to apply it

  1. Use structured criteria when selecting leaders for clubs, committees or jobs.
  2. Mentor and sponsor. Mentors advise; sponsors actively recommend people for opportunities. Both matter.
  3. Challenge biased language such as "too emotional" or "bossy" when you hear it.
  4. Share domestic and caring work fairly, and support flexible arrangements in your organisation.
  5. Encourage women to stand for leadership roles, and make meetings safe for them to speak. See Inclusive Leadership.

Key points

  • The labyrinth (Eagly & Carli, 2007) describes many obstacles throughout women's careers, not a single ceiling.
  • Men and women differ little in leadership style and effectiveness.
  • The gap is explained mainly by unequal opportunities and prejudice, not lack of ability or commitment.
  • The double bind traps women between communal and agentic expectations.
Up next · New chapter: Leadership in PracticeLeading YourselfSelf-awareness, discipline and setting the example.
→

Tip: use the ← and → keys to move between pages.