Decision-Making for Leaders
Leaders make decisions every day, from small calls about meeting times to big choices about money and people. Good decision-making is not about always being right; it is about following a sound process, involving the right people and learning from the results.
A simple decision process
- Define the problem. What exactly needs deciding, and by when? A badly defined problem leads to good answers to the wrong question.
- Gather information. Get facts, and ask people affected by the decision.
- Generate options. Aim for at least three before choosing.
- Set criteria. Cost, time, fairness, risk, fit with your values.
- Decide and communicate the decision and the reasons behind it.
- Review. After implementation, ask what worked and what you'd change.
How much should others be involved?
Robert Tannenbaum and Warren Schmidt (1958) described a continuum of leader behaviour, from the leader deciding alone to the group deciding within limits the leader sets. Later, Victor Vroom and Philip Yetton (1973) developed a model to help leaders choose how much participation to use, depending on factors such as how important decision quality is, how much information the leader has, and whether followers' acceptance is needed for success.
| Approach | When it fits | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Decide alone | Urgent, routine, or you have all the information and acceptance is likely | Rescheduling a meeting because the hall is double-booked |
| Consult, then decide | You need others' information or ideas, but responsibility rests with you | Choosing a supplier after asking committee members for quotes |
| Decide together | Commitment matters, and the group has the knowledge to decide well | Agreeing a team's working norms |
| Delegate | Others are competent and committed; it develops them | Letting an experienced member plan the end-of-year event |
This links to path-goal theory (participative leadership suits people who want control) and situational leadership (delegating suits highly developed followers).
Useful tools
The urgent-important matrix
Often linked to US President Dwight Eisenhower and popularised by Stephen Covey, this sorts tasks into four boxes: urgent and important (do now), important but not urgent (schedule), urgent but not important (delegate if possible), and neither (drop). Leaders who spend time on important-but-not-urgent tasks, such as planning and developing people, prevent many crises.
The pre-mortem
Psychologist Gary Klein suggested imagining that your plan has already failed, then asking: "What went wrong?" This surfaces risks people might hesitate to mention.
Traps to avoid
- Groupthink, described by Irving Janis in 1972: a close group values agreement so much that it stops thinking critically. Invite a "devil's advocate".
- Confirmation bias: noticing only information that supports what you already believe.
- Sunk cost thinking: continuing a failing project because you have already invested in it.
- Deciding while angry or exhausted. If it can wait until tomorrow, let it.
A youth group in Moshi has KES 120,000 from a fundraiser. Members argue over whether to buy a sound system or fund school fees for two members. The chair, Rehema, defines the decision clearly, lists criteria agreed by the group (impact, fairness, sustainability), and asks people to suggest options. A third option emerges: buy a modest sound system to rent out for events and use the income for a small bursary fund. A pre-mortem reveals the risk of equipment theft, so they add a storage plan. Because members shaped the decision, they back it fully.
Key points
- Follow a process: define, gather, generate options, set criteria, decide, review.
- Match the level of participation to the situation (Tannenbaum & Schmidt; Vroom & Yetton).
- Tools such as the urgent-important matrix and the pre-mortem improve decisions.
- Watch for groupthink, confirmation bias and sunk cost thinking.
Tip: use the ← and → keys to move between pages.
