The Trait Approach
The trait approach asks a simple question: what personal characteristics do effective leaders have? It was one of the first systematic attempts to study leadership, and although its early promise faded, a century of research has identified a handful of traits that are consistently linked with leaders.
What the approach says
From "great man" theories to research
In the early twentieth century, leadership was studied through so-called "great man" theories, which looked for the innate qualities of famous political, military and social leaders. The assumption was that leaders are born with special characteristics.
In 1948, Ralph Stogdill reviewed more than a hundred trait studies and reached an important conclusion: no consistent set of traits separated leaders from non-leaders across all situations. A person who leads well in one setting may not lead well in another. This shifted research towards behaviour and situations. However, Stogdill's second major review in 1974 gave traits a more balanced role, finding that certain characteristics did relate to leadership, alongside situational factors. Later work, including reviews by Robert Lord and colleagues (1986) and by Shelley Kirkpatrick and Edwin Locke (1991), renewed interest in traits.
Major leadership traits
Different studies produce different lists, but five traits appear repeatedly in the research summarised by Northouse:
| Trait | What it involves |
|---|---|
| Intelligence | Strong verbal, perceptual and reasoning ability. Leaders tend to be brighter than average, though a very large gap between leader and followers can make communication harder. |
| Self-confidence | Certainty about one's competence and skills, including self-esteem and belief that one can make a difference. |
| Determination | The drive to get the job done: initiative, persistence and willingness to assert oneself. |
| Integrity | Honesty and trustworthiness; taking responsibility for one's actions. |
| Sociability | Seeking out pleasant relationships; being friendly, tactful and diplomatic. |
The Big Five and emotional intelligence
A 2002 meta-analysis by Timothy Judge, Joyce Bono, Remus Ilies and Megan Gerhardt examined the "Big Five" personality factors. Extraversion was the factor most strongly linked to leadership, followed by conscientiousness and openness to experience. Neuroticism was negatively related, and agreeableness was only weakly related.
Researchers have also studied emotional intelligence: the ability to perceive, understand and manage emotions in yourself and others. The idea was developed by Peter Salovey and John Mayer and popularised by Daniel Goleman. Many argue that people who are sensitive to emotions are more effective leaders, although the research evidence is still debated.
An example
A church in Mbarara needs to choose a new youth coordinator. The selection committee shortlists two candidates.
- Joseph is outgoing and confident, with strong grades, but has twice left commitments unfinished.
- Ruth is quieter but warm and well liked, runs the Sunday school roster flawlessly and is known for honesty when things go wrong.
Thinking in trait terms, the committee notices that Joseph scores highly on self-confidence and extraversion, while Ruth shows determination, integrity, sociability and conscientiousness. They decide that trustworthiness and follow-through matter most for a role handling young people and offerings, and choose Ruth, while inviting Joseph to lead the worship team, where his energy is a strength.
Strengths
- Intuitive appeal. It fits the common belief that leaders are special people who are out in front.
- A large body of research. More than a century of studies gives it credibility that newer theories lack.
- Focus on the leader. It highlights the leader's role in the process and what qualities matter.
- Benchmarks. It gives organisations and individuals a sense of which traits to look for and develop.
Criticisms
- No definitive list. Studies have produced long, overlapping and sometimes contradictory lists of traits.
- Ignores the situation. Traits that help in one context may not help in another.
- Subjective choices. Many "most important trait" lists rely on interpretation rather than strong evidence.
- Weak link to outcomes. Research shows traits relate to who emerges as leader more than to team performance.
- Limited use for training. Traits are relatively stable, so teaching them is difficult compared with teaching skills or behaviours.
How to apply it
- Know your profile. Reflect honestly, or use a reputable personality assessment, to see which traits are strengths.
- Find roles that fit. Place yourself where your traits help the group.
- Guard integrity above all. Of all the traits, honesty is the one you fully control and the one followers value most.
- Compensate, don't pretend. If you are introverted, you can still lead well by preparing, listening and building one-to-one trust.
- Move on to skills. Traits are only part of the story; see The Skills Approach.
Key points
- The trait approach looks for personal characteristics associated with leaders.
- Stogdill (1948) found traits alone did not predict leadership across situations.
- Commonly identified traits are intelligence, self-confidence, determination, integrity and sociability.
- Extraversion is the Big Five factor most strongly linked to leadership (Judge et al., 2002).
- The approach ignores situations and is hard to use for training.
Tip: use the ← and → keys to move between pages.
