Skip to content
Kuza Ndoto Academy

Situational Leadership

All levelsChapter 3 · Page 8 of 264 min readUpdated 15 Nov 2026

Situational leadership is built on a simple idea: different people, and the same person at different times, need different kinds of leadership. An effective leader reads where a follower is on a particular task and adjusts how much direction and support they give.

What the approach says

The approach was developed by Paul Hersey and Kenneth Blanchard in 1969. It was later revised by Blanchard and colleagues into the version known as Situational Leadership II (SLII), which is the version described here.

Two kinds of leader behaviour

  • Directive behaviours help people accomplish a goal by telling them what to do, how, when and by whom it will be judged. Communication is mostly one-way.
  • Supportive behaviours help people feel good about themselves, their colleagues and the situation: listening, praising, asking for input and sharing information. Communication is two-way.

Development levels

A follower's development level is the degree to which they have the competence and commitment to do a specific task. People are not at one level for everything: a student can be highly developed at football training and a beginner at writing funding proposals.

Matching styles to development levels

Development levelCompetence and commitmentMatching styleLeader behaviour
D1Low competence, high commitment: new to the task but excitedS1 DirectingHigh directive, low supportive. Give clear instructions and supervise closely.
D2Some competence, low commitment: has started learning but feels discouragedS2 CoachingHigh directive, high supportive. Keep giving direction, but also explain, encourage and invite input.
D3Moderate to high competence, variable commitment: skilled but unsure or hesitantS3 SupportingLow directive, high supportive. Listen, encourage and help the person use their own skills.
D4High competence, high commitment: skilled and motivatedS4 DelegatingLow directive, low supportive. Hand over responsibility and trust the person to get on with it.

Followers move forwards and sometimes backwards through the levels, so the leader must keep diagnosing and adjusting. Leading well means being flexible, not having one favourite style.

S3 Supporting high supportive, low directive S2 Coaching high directive, high supportive S4 Delegating low supportive, low directive S1 Directing high directive, low supportive Supportive behaviour low high Directive behaviour Development level D4 D3 D2 D1 developed developing
Figure 1. Based on Hersey and Blanchard's situational leadership model (SLII version). Diagnose the follower's development level on the scale below, then use the matching style above: D1 with S1, D2 with S2, D3 with S3 and D4 with S4.

An example

Example

Neema leads a five-person team running a youth savings group project for a community-based organisation in Arusha.

  • Baraka has just joined and is eager to learn how to record contributions (D1). Neema shows him exactly how to fill in the ledger and checks his entries daily (S1).
  • Zawadi has done the records for a month but is frustrated by errors and complaints (D2). Neema still checks her work but also explains why reconciliation matters and praises her progress (S2).
  • Hussein knows the work well but is nervous about presenting to the board (D3). Neema doesn't tell him what to say; she asks how he plans it and boosts his confidence (S3).
  • Esther has run savings groups for three years (D4). Neema gives her the new village to set up and checks in only at month end (S4).

Strengths

  • Practical and easy to understand. It is widely used in leadership training around the world.
  • Prescriptive. It tells you what to do in a given situation, not just what is happening.
  • Emphasises flexibility. Leaders learn to adapt rather than use one style for everyone.
  • Treats people as individuals and focuses on helping each person develop.

Criticisms

  • Limited research. Relatively few published studies test its assumptions and propositions.
  • Unclear development levels. It is not fully explained why competence and commitment combine as they do, and the descriptions of the levels have changed across versions.
  • Commitment is vague. It is unclear whether commitment means confidence, motivation or both.
  • Individual differences. Studies suggest factors like age, education and experience affect which style people prefer, which the model does not fully address.
  • Groups versus individuals. It does not clearly explain how to lead a whole group whose members are at different levels.

How to apply it

  1. Pick a specific task rather than judging a person overall.
  2. Diagnose competence and commitment. Ask: can they do it? Do they want to and feel confident?
  3. Choose the matching style using the table above.
  4. Tell people what you are doing. Saying "I'll check in daily while you learn this, then step back" prevents your direction feeling like distrust.
  5. Reassess regularly and move towards delegating as people grow.

Key points

  • Situational leadership (Hersey & Blanchard; SLII by Blanchard and colleagues) matches leader style to follower development.
  • Leader behaviour is a mix of directive and supportive behaviours.
  • Development levels D1 to D4 combine competence and commitment for a specific task.
  • D1 to S1 directing, D2 to S2 coaching, D3 to S3 supporting, D4 to S4 delegating.
Up next · Situational & Relational ApproachesPath-Goal TheoryChoose leader behaviours that clear the path to followers' goals.
→

Tip: use the ← and → keys to move between pages.