Ethical Leadership
Every leadership decision affects people, so every leader faces ethical questions. Ethical leadership is about the kind of person a leader is and the actions they take, and about using influence in ways that respect others and serve the common good.
What the approach says
Ethical theories
Ethical theories fall into two broad groups: theories about a leader's conduct and theories about a leader's character.
| Group | Theory | Central question |
|---|---|---|
| Conduct: consequences | Ethical egoism | What is best for me? (acting in self-interest) |
| Conduct: consequences | Utilitarianism | What creates the greatest good for the greatest number of people? |
| Conduct: consequences | Altruism | What is best for others, even at some cost to me? |
| Conduct: duty | Deontology | Is the action itself right, regardless of its results? (e.g. telling the truth, keeping promises) |
| Character | Virtue-based ethics | What kind of person should I be? (courage, honesty, fairness, temperance) |
Virtue ethics goes back to Plato and Aristotle and emphasises that virtues are learned through practice, much like leadership skills.
Five principles of ethical leadership
Northouse brings together a long tradition of moral philosophy and leadership writing into five principles:
| Principle | What it requires of a leader |
|---|---|
| Respect | Treating others as ends in themselves, never just as means to your goals (an idea from the philosopher Immanuel Kant). Listening, valuing opinions and accepting disagreement. |
| Service | Putting followers' welfare first and contributing to the greater good, as in mentoring and empowerment. |
| Justice | Treating people fairly and making fairness central to decisions. Different treatment must be based on clear, defensible reasons. |
| Honesty | Being truthful and open, while handling information with appropriate sensitivity. Dishonesty destroys trust. |
| Community | Pursuing goals that benefit the whole group, not just the leader, and considering the wider community. |
Other writers have shaped thinking on leadership ethics. Ronald Heifetz argued leaders should help followers face difficult values conflicts; Burns stressed raising followers' moral development; and Greenleaf emphasised serving others (see Servant Leadership).
An example
Daudi is a procurement officer at a county government office in Nyeri. A supplier offers him a "thank you" of KES 50,000 if he speeds up their tender, and his supervisor hints that this is normal.
- Honesty: he declines the money and records the offer in line with procurement rules.
- Justice: he makes sure all bidders are scored using the same published criteria.
- Respect: he explains his position to his supervisor calmly, without accusing anyone.
- Community: he reminds the team that the tender is for a water project that thousands of residents depend on.
- Service: he later helps colleagues understand the rules so they feel less pressure.
His choice carries personal risk, which is why ethical leadership often requires courage.
Strengths
- Timely. Corruption and scandals in politics, business and religious bodies make ethics essential.
- Gives direction on how leaders should behave, not just how they do behave.
- Treats ethics as central to leadership, since leaders' influence carries responsibility.
- Highlights character and values, linking leadership to who we are.
Criticisms
- Early stage of research. There is less empirical study of ethical leadership than of many other approaches.
- Relies on a limited set of writers whose work is often philosophical rather than tested.
- Principles can conflict. Honesty and respect, or justice and service, may pull in different directions, and the principles do not always tell you how to resolve this.
- Culture and context. What counts as fair or respectful can vary between settings.
How to apply it
- Use a quick test before decisions: Is it legal? Is it fair to everyone affected? Would I be comfortable if it appeared on the front page of a newspaper?
- Apply more than one lens. Think about consequences, duties and what a person of good character would do.
- Be transparent with money and power. Publish accounts in your club or SACCO.
- Find an ethical ally: someone you trust to talk through hard calls.
- Practise small honesty daily. Character is built in small choices before big ones arrive.
Key points
- Ethical theories focus on conduct (consequences or duty) or character (virtues).
- Five principles of ethical leadership: respect, service, justice, honesty and community.
- Leaders have special ethical responsibility because of their influence.
- Ethical leadership often requires courage, especially where corruption is normalised.
Tip: use the ← and → keys to move between pages.
