Followership
Most of the time, most of us are followers. Followership is the study of how followers think, behave and influence leaders. Good followers are not passive; they help shape decisions, challenge mistakes and make leadership succeed.
What the approach says
For decades, leadership research focused almost entirely on leaders. Since the late twentieth century, scholars have argued that leadership cannot be understood without followers. Some study followership as a role (how people in follower positions behave), while others see it as something co-created in the interactions between people.
Kelley's typology
Robert Kelley, in The Power of Followership (1992), described followers using two dimensions:
- Independent, critical thinking versus dependent, uncritical thinking.
- Active versus passive engagement.
| Follower type | Thinking | Engagement | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| Exemplary | Independent, critical | Active | Thinks for themselves, gives honest input and works energetically for the group. |
| Alienated | Independent, critical | Passive | Sees problems clearly but has withdrawn; often cynical. |
| Conformist | Dependent, uncritical | Active | Enthusiastically does what they are told but rarely questions ("yes people"). |
| Passive | Dependent, uncritical | Passive | Relies on the leader for thinking and needs constant direction. |
| Pragmatist | In the middle | In the middle | Waits to see which way the wind blows; supports the status quo. |
Other perspectives
- Barbara Kellerman (2008) classified followers by their level of engagement: isolates (completely detached), bystanders (observe but don't act), participants (engaged and willing to invest), activists (strongly committed for or against the leader) and diehards (deeply devoted, willing to risk a great deal).
- Ira Chaleff wrote about the courageous follower, who supports the leader but also has the courage to challenge and, when necessary, refuse unethical demands.
When followership goes wrong
Followers are also responsible when things go badly. Harmful leaders often succeed because followers stay silent, obey without question or benefit personally. Good followership includes speaking up about corruption, abuse or unsafe practices.
An example
At a Kampala marketing agency, the director decides to promise a client a full campaign in one week. Three junior staff react differently:
- Brian says "Yes, boss!" and starts work immediately, though he knows the deadline is impossible (conformist).
- Patience complains to colleagues at lunch but says nothing in the meeting (alienated).
- Ivan respectfully explains that design approval alone takes three days, proposes a two-week plan with a quick first draft, and volunteers to lead the copy (exemplary).
The director adopts Ivan's plan. The client is satisfied, and Ivan's influence in the team grows: an example of leading from a follower position.
Strengths
- Gives followers their due as active contributors to leadership.
- Encourages shared responsibility for outcomes, good and bad.
- Practical value. Typologies help individuals reflect on how they follow.
- Helps leaders understand and develop the people they lead.
Criticisms
- Young field. Research is limited, and many typologies are descriptive rather than tested.
- Multiple competing frameworks make it hard to build a single theory.
- Simplifies people. Real followers move between types depending on the leader and situation.
- Context matters. In some cultures and organisations, challenging a leader carries high risks.
How to apply it
- Identify your default type in a current group. Are you active? Are you thinking critically?
- Bring solutions, not just problems, when you disagree.
- Choose the right moment and channel to challenge: privately first, respectfully, with evidence.
- Know your limits. Decide in advance what you will refuse to do, even if asked by someone senior.
- As a leader, reward people who disagree constructively, so exemplary followers don't become alienated. See also LMX.
Key points
- Followership studies how followers think, act and shape leadership.
- Kelley (1992): exemplary, alienated, conformist, passive and pragmatist followers.
- Kellerman (2008): isolates, bystanders, participants, activists and diehards.
- Good followers are active, independent thinkers who support the goal and challenge wrongdoing.
Tip: use the ← and → keys to move between pages.
