Trait vs. Process, Assigned vs. Emergent
Is leadership something you have or something you do? And does it come from being appointed, or from how a group responds to you? These two questions give us two useful distinctions: trait versus process leadership, and assigned versus emergent leadership.
Trait leadership versus process leadership
The trait perspective says that leadership lives inside certain individuals. On this view, people who become leaders possess special qualities, such as confidence, height, intelligence or a commanding voice, that others lack. Leadership is limited to a gifted few.
The process perspective says that leadership is a phenomenon that happens in the interaction between a leader and followers. It can be observed in behaviour, and because behaviour can be learned, leadership is available to everyone.
| Trait perspective | Process perspective | |
|---|---|---|
| Where leadership lives | In the person | In the relationship between leader and followers |
| Who can lead | People with the "right" qualities | Anyone, through what they do |
| Can it be developed? | Only to a limited extent | Yes, through learning and practice |
| Typical question | "Does she have what it takes?" | "What is she doing that people respond to?" |
The two are not completely opposed. Research covered on The Trait Approach page shows that some characteristics are consistently linked with leadership. But most of the theories in this series take the process view, because it explains how ordinary people become effective leaders.
Assigned leadership versus emergent leadership
Assigned leadership comes from holding a formal position: head prefect, team leader, county director, imam, pastor or class representative. The organisation gives the person authority.
Emergent leadership happens when a group comes to see a person as its leader because of how they behave, regardless of their title. Emergent leaders are not appointed; they are recognised by others over time.
| Assigned | Emergent | |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Appointment or election to a role | Group acceptance and support |
| Example | The supervisor named on the organisation chart | The intern everyone asks when they are stuck |
| Risk | Title without real influence | Influence without formal authority to act |
The person in the assigned role is not always the person the group actually follows. Effective organisations try to put people with genuine influence into formal roles, and wise assigned leaders work with the emergent leaders around them rather than competing with them.
What helps someone emerge as a leader?
Studies of small groups suggest that people tend to emerge as leaders when they take part actively, appear well informed, ask for others' views, offer new ideas and hold their position firmly but respectfully. Personality also plays a part, and so does the group's context. Unfortunately, stereotypes play a part too: research shows that people sometimes overlook capable women or members of minority groups when deciding who "looks like" a leader. You will explore this on Gender & Leadership.
A fintech start-up in Kigali appoints Eric as product manager. In meetings, however, the developers keep turning to Grace, a junior engineer who explains technical trade-offs clearly and makes sure quieter colleagues are heard. Eric holds assigned leadership; Grace shows emergent leadership.
Eric has two options. He can feel threatened and sideline Grace, or he can recognise her influence, involve her in planning and give her ownership of technical decisions. He chooses the second. Product decisions improve, and six months later Grace is formally made technical lead.
Why these distinctions matter to you
- If you hold a title, do not assume the title alone makes people follow you. Influence must be earned through behaviour.
- If you have no title, you can still lead: take initiative, help the group, and build trust.
- If you believe leadership is a trait you lack, the process view is good news. The skills and behaviours in this series can be practised.
Key points
- The trait view places leadership in special individuals; the process view places it in interactions anyone can learn.
- Assigned leadership comes from a formal position; emergent leadership comes from group recognition.
- The formal leader and the person the group actually follows are not always the same.
- Stereotypes can affect who is seen as a leader, so emergence is not always fair.
Tip: use the ← and → keys to move between pages.
